Them! Us!

I chose these two stills because they represent a common theme throughout the documentary. Climate change and evolution, down to a molecular and single celled level is constantly discussed. In the first still, the science fiction movie they are watching is dealing with evolved creatures that are now taking over the world. Much like the science fiction movie they are watching, life not visible to the naked eye is doing just that. Herzog really gets the viewer thinking about how we as humans evolved from single celled organisms and in the second still, the scientists discuss how this single celled organism is actually demonstrating intelligent processes by separating and gathering grains of sand to protect its flimsy body by forming a rigid exoskeleton. Herzog’s open ended questions to experts on the topics they are discussing leave much up to vivid interpretation by the viewer and is much more interesting to watch than a cut and dried, scripted documentary.  The comparisons between the science fiction and the wild, undisturbed wilderness and vast expanses of underwater scenery place the viewer in a position to really start to question their existence and the reasons for our day to day actions and choices in life.

Ideal Truth

I chose to compare these two scenes because I think they interchange relationships between humans and animals and the idea of truth. In the first still, the penguin knows his truth and has decided he will waddle his way into central Antarctica to certain death. They state in the film that there would be no use in trying to stop this penguin because he would most certainly make his way back to the exact spot. In the second still, scientists have their ears to the ice trying to listen to hypnotic seal sounds. The scientists have instruments they use to listen to the seal sounds, which resemble that of science-fiction noises. The imagery of these scientists listening to the ice gives more light to the idea of a world on the other side, which can be said of the same for the penguin in the first still, he is wandering into a new, unknown, world. I suggested the interchange between human and animals because the penguin in the first still is very determined to exhume his truth while the scientists are using more animal like tactics (never mind the instruments) by laying on the ice listening for seal sounds. The ideas of many different worlds comes from Herzog’s belief that truth can be fabricated through poetic and artistic choices.