“guest” gif

via GIPHY

I chose this clip after the discussion we had in class on Wednesday about the appropriateness of calling the Turkish “guest” workers when they were in fact not guests at all. I thought this short clip from the beginning of the film truly shed light on that fact and helped me better understand the context of our discussion. In my gif you can see the “guest” workers entering Germany and being inspected like an animal almost. They are being numbered and made to remove their clothing. While Almanya was a more lighthearted recount of this time in history, this first scene or two expresses the notion that these people weren’t “guests” so much as a menial labor force.

A Flash of the Past

via GIPHY

This scene is at the very end of the movie when the family is leaving their small village in Turkey as well as their beloved grandfather behind. I think this scene shows how the film came full circle. Cenk, as the youngest in the family, is trying to imagine and replay the stories Canan had been telling him of their family and journey to Germany. This film follows the history of guest workers but, more specifically, the story of this certain family. This scene shows the memory, history, and cultural identity that was important to this family during the time of their migration and within the many generations that followed.

Hüseyin’s Naiveté: the ironic hopefulness of a “guest worker”

 

This GIF highlights Hüseyin’s naiveté about moving to Germany as a guest worker. Here we see him grinning hopefully at the welcoming speech delivered upon his arrival. As we have discussed in class, “guest workers” that migrated to Germany in the 1960s and 1970s were not always treated as guests. They worked low-level jobs and were separated from their families for long periods of time. Moreover, they struggled to assimilate into an unwelcoming culture, while also juggling the need to maintain their own. The 1970 Der Spiegel article “Komm, Komm, Komm – Geh, Geh, Geh” remembers of these migrant laborers, “They are not given any gifts; they do not enjoy any special status; they are only invited to join in the production process.” Almanya: Willkommen in Deutschland touches upon these topics. It depicts Hüseyin working subordinate jobs and pining for his family back home in Turkey. And while the film engages thoroughly with a people balancing two cultures at once, it does not fully express the consequences of battling social disparities. Rather, the film glosses over these challenges with rose-tinted comedy. This GIF offers one such example. Hüseyin venerates his new identity as a “guest worker.” His nod is ironic and laughable because it indicates that he believes his new position is a respectable and desirable one, when the reality is quite the opposite. Though the film recognizes the irony in this moment, it does not stress just how seriously Hüseyin is mistaken, when he can really only expect long days on the job, and long nights away from home. On the other hand, it can be argued that the film uses comedy to bring to light these hardships, and I shall be curious to see whether such an argument is made…