The Quantified Self

Day 1, Nov 22 – Prior choosing to measure my screen time I hadn’t actually ever taken the time to check for myself. As my experiment would follow I checked my phone’s screen time option in order to tell how long I used my phone on that day. Upon checking the first day, to my suprise, my screen time was calculated at six hours and 43 minutes. This surprised me as I would’ve never imagined that I would be on my phone almost 7 hours out of the day. 

 

Day 2, Nov 23 – Despite having somewhat of a disappointing screen time the day before I was quite proud of today’s data. Cutting my past screen time by two hours I only spent four hours and 53 minutes on my phone today.  I’ve also found a tool that tells you how much time you’ve spent on certain apps. It appears most of my screen time is spent on social media and entertainment apps.  

 

Day 3, Nov 24 – Overall, l definitely wouldn’t mark today’s screen time as improvement. Ultimately my screen time was found to be at nine hours and 45 minutes. While some of this may be mainly caused due to being in the car for three hours this is still definitely alarming. On a separate note, I’ve begun to find it increasingly more noticeable when I take my phone out to use it, rather than before when it was a subconscious act. 

 

Day 4, Nov 25 – While I also wasn’t the busiest today, I found that I had made a major improvement in comparison to yesterday’s screen time. At the end of the day I found my screen time to be only four hours and 23 minutes. I’m currently in Long Island at a family member’s house spending time with my siblings and family. I’ve also watched a good amount of movies which may explain the low amount of screen time.  

 

Day 5, Nov 26 – I’ve been pretty occupied today going on walks and spending time with family for Thanksgiving. At the end of the day I found my screen time to be at five hours and 19 minutes. I found that a lot of this time came from some of the music apps I use which may have had an effect during my time driving, and not actually being on my phone. Regardless, I still found 5 hours and 19 minutes to be a satisfying amount of screen time. 

 

Day 6, Nov 27 – Today I drove home from Long Island, which is a three hours drive. As you may recall from day 3, the last time I had taken this drive, my screen time was reported at nine hours and 45 minutes. However, this time I slept during most of the car ride and it made all the difference. At the end of the day my screen time was four hours and 26 minutes. Being in similar circumstances to a time when my screen time was at its most high I was able to cut my screen time in half. 

 

Day 7, Nov 28 – While most of my day revolved around preparing for my brother’s confirmation, I still made some room for my phone. At the end of the day, and after a two hour confirmation, my screen time was reportedly calculated at four hours and 46 minutes. After finding my screen time to be close to seven hours, on day 1, I felt very compelled to limit my phone usage. After reaching multiple days having under, or close to, five hours of screen time, I feel very accomplished. I’ve also found that screen time when using social media apps is still the single greatest factor while entertainment has decreased exponentially, which now may be something to consider. 

 

Lukas Comerico

The Quantified Self

 

Upon deciding to pursue an interest in the quantified self, and doing some background research, I found that while the quantified self is an overthought term it is far more simple in nature. By definition the quantified self completed is “the act of using personal data to improve one’s quality of life.” In other words, the quantified self involves those who pursue tracking their personal data, mostly through technology, in attempt to better themselves. Overall, the qualified self ties with simply looking at your life and finding things you want to change, however, through data collective and analysis. Hypothetically, if an individual recently became unsatisfied with their calorie intake then the quantified self is a very helpful strategy. For example, after each meal or day of eating the individual is able to calculate exactly how many calories they’ve consumed. Whether this is done manually or through use of an easier calorie measuring tool, like a fitbit, that individual should be able to pick out eating patterns in which they would like to fix. Through analyzing eating patterns over a series of days, an individual should be more immersed in their calorie intake than ever before, moreover being able to see the specific problem and act on it. Through the quantified self, by directly focusing on one or more certain aspects of your life and realizing how these aspects affect you, it becomes far easier to willingly make better choices about your life when dealing with those aspects. 

 

After first looking over the project prompts I already found that I had a major interest in the quantified self. While this may be because one of the biggest takeaways was a sense of self improvement, I also found the concept to be intriguing and interesting. While the importance of self improvement will most likely vary from person to person I’ve always found myself to be strong at building upon myself and for myself. As a result, for my project I choose to analyze the amount of screen time I spent on my phone daily, throughout one week. Another reason I choose to measure my screen time is because I actually never had before and was very eager to learn how much time I spent on my phone per day. 

 

My overall goal through my project was to calculate an average amount of hours I spend on my phone per day and limit that to an amount that I’m satisfied with. I found this to be the most important because I assume this is something almost everyone my age thinks about. In an age where everything is being digitized it should still be just as important to witness the real world and not be constantly drawn to our phones.

 

In order to gather data and analyze my daily screen time I used a tool that apple offers freely. Within settings I found an area called screen time on my Iphone, that anyone with an apple should have free access to. Here I found that an amount calculated in hours and minutes measured by screen time every single day. This would allow me to figure out exactly how long I used my phone on a given day and specifically at what time during the day. I found this extremely useful as when I would go back at the end of the day I would remember certain circumstances where I remembered using my phone for specific instances. I found knowing that I used my phone for a specific and useful reason reassuring because that meant I wasn’t wasting my time looking at something useless. On the third day however I was enlightened to another option that I found to be even more beneficial. By looking at your daily screen time and scrolling down a tiny bit I was able to see how long I had spent using certain apps. I found this extremely beneficial because then I was able to tell what specific apps I was overusing rather than just knowing I was overusing my phone in general. 

Words Cited

 

Peters, Katelyn. “Quantified Self.” Investopedia, Investopedia, 26 Sept. 2020, www.investopedia.com/terms/q/quantified-self.asp. 

 

Final Counter-Surveillance as a Form of Protection Seth Cullen

Dec 1.  Day one of becoming “digitally woke” I decided to start by switching from Google to Duckduckgo.  Duckduckgo is a search engine with all the features google has, such as images, videos, news, and maps.  The fundamental difference of Duckduckgo is that it does not collect and sell your search data.  I would like to add another benefit is that because your search data is not stored each time you search you receive an unbiased result.

 

Dec 2.  I was happy with the new feel of Duckduckgo, so I decided to switch to another browser. Tor was the first and obvious choice.  The makers of Tor have a mission of ending the “digital fingerprint” which is a unique series of information on your computer hardware.  Tor is not as pretty or smooth as Firefox or Google Chrome, but I think the mission it stands for is worth the switch.

 

Dec 3.  For day three I must go back in time.  A little over a year ago I set a Pihole in my house. Pihole is an ad blocker that works on all devices on your internet.  It is highly configurable with an administrator portal.  The setup is not easy for people with little programing experience.  You must buy a Raspberry Pi and configure the software to work as a Pi-hole.  My family and I really enjoy having no ads, and it also increases the speed in which websites load.

 

Dec 4.  Day four is still in the past shortly after making the Pi-hole I decided the next step was to setup a household VPN using Open VPN.  The setup for the VPN is similar to the Pi-hole and I was able to put it on the same Raspberry Pi. The benefits of having the VPN hosted from my house are that I can access devices on my network from anywhere. The VPN also ads an extra layer of security when accessing my network. Having a VPN also stops your internet service provider for tracking you.

 

Dec 5. Today I bought five dollars’ worth of bitcoin or 0.00026000 of one coin.  Bitcoin is a useful way to take back your privacy from being tracked for purchases online and even at some stores and restaurants.  Bitcoin is encrypted end to end on transactions.  There are no receipts to track your uses of bitcoin.

 

Dec 6.  I wanted to use a new email service that was encrypted.  I did some research and decided to try Protonmail hosted in Switzerland.  The service has a mobile app that syncs with the desktop and is user friendly.  A great feature of using the service is that Swiss privacy laws cover it.  The biggest downside of using the service is that if you lose your password your account is gone if you do not have a recovery email set.  The service is similar to any other email, but the user interface is nothing exciting.

 

Dec 7.  Today I decided to do a check on what comes up on me online using OneRep.  The service informed me of 17 different websites where my information was available, including where I was from and my phone number. I investigated one of the websites that had my information, it was called social catfish. The website claims to be able to reveal info on people such as usernames, arrest records, previous relationships, and other sensitive information.  But once the scan of myself was done it had me under a different last name, and I did not want to pay to see someone else’s information.  OneRep claims to remove the information from the websites it finds, but it charges a fee, so I am unsure if it is worth paying for.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Counter-surveillance is a form of protecting oneself from being surveilled.  The ways in which I used counter-surveillance to take back my online privacy were Duckduckgo, Tor, Pi-hole, Open VPN, Bitcoin, Protonmail, and OneRep.  I used Duckduckgo to stop having my search data collected, used, and sold by Google. I used Tor to erase my digital fingerprint.  I made a Pi-hole in order to remove ads while using internet browsers on all devices in my home.  I set up Open VPN to stop my internet service provider from tracking me online.  I bought Bitcoin to purchase stuff online without a trace.  I created a Protonmail account to send encrypted emails. I scanned myself with OneRep to see what information of mine was available online.

My goal in using the aforementioned counter-surveillance techniques was to take a step in gaining back my online privacy.  I would also like to spread awareness of what steps you can take to protect our data online.  Additionally, I would like to inform readers about the ways that websites, apps, and other services collect, store, and track our data.  I believe that we need to take a stand and draw the line on what information is taken, and who can take and see it.

The self-knowledge I gained from taking back my online privacy were: how much data is collected, who collects the data, and how my data is used.  After learning of how my data was being taken advantage of I realized that I am not okay with it anymore.  I learned of new ways to take back my privacy online.  Taking the steps that I did make me feel much more secure in my online activities.

Data becomes valuable information to me when it can be used against me in any way, such as spam callers contacting me, or my phone location being used to track me. It is under uses like those that it can be manipulated to cause impacts on society.  Data is also valuable in predicting the behavior of different groups of people.  This can have negative side effects, especially when used in terms of race, gender, or country of origin.

If I were to have my own terms of service, they would allow for less data collection.  I would allow for data to be collected that is anonymous, meaning that the data could be collected but not linked back to me.  The data would be for purposes of improving services related to the data, such as improving algorithms.  I also would like for the data to not be stored for more than thirty days.  I also am not okay with information on my computer’s hardware being collected such as monitor sizer, or what video card is installed.  Additionally, I would like the data to be encrypted end to end when being collected so it is not subject to an outsider attack while data is transferring.  I am okay with my data being collected so long as it meets these terms and has a benefit for the website or service that is useful to the community and myself.  These are my five rules for equity and fairness when it comes to data sharing.

I have become a big fan of Duckduckgo, I installed their additional browser extension for Firefox.  Overall, I think the community that uses Duckduckgo is fed up with Google and other companies that collect and use their data. Duckduckgo is unbiased, and in my opinion that provides greater search results.

I will not use Tor as my daily browser just because it lacks some features of Firefox that I have grown used to. I like the goal of Tor to reduce and eliminate digital fingerprints.  I also like how it is open source and transmits your privacy thought the community.  The idea of Tor is very appealing to have an anonymous internet, but it is honestly unpractical for daily use.

I cannot express in words how happy I have been with my Pi-hole. The community is regularly active on Reddit and you can get responses to any questions within hours.  I have been working on computers for years.  I had done some work on Raspberry Pis before, but this was by far the most user-friendly installation I had ever done.  I did what is referred to as a headless installation, meaning I did not connect the pi to a monitor, instead I remoted into it from my computer.  The whole process took under thirty minutes, I have had to do little updating to the list of sources to block from and there are lists you can copy online.

Open VPN was extremely useful until I moved, and my configuration no longer worked. I liked being able to remote into my network and use my devices from anywhere. I connected to it if wanted to connect to unsecure Wi-Fi and not have them see my data.

My bitcoin will fluctuate in value and likely increase after a while. I look forward to spending my bitcoin in the future anonymously. I think the way how algorithms make the transactions happen is incredibly unique and interesting.

Protonmail is a service that I believe could be developed to become a main source of email.  The Swiss take their online privacy seriously, and since Protonmail is hosted in Switzerland you benefit from their privacy laws.

OneRep is a website that looks online based on your name and location to what pops up online about you and what websites that information is available.  I was not happy with the idea of paying them to remove data that I could not see, and I would not recommend using their services.

My findings from the group reflection are that we used similar strategies of taking back our online privacy. Michael, Harrison, and I all used Duckduckgo which is a great tool for taking back online privacy.

Counter Surveillance and Taking Agency Over Yourself

Harrison Paul

Dr. Koellner

German Lit in Translation

8 December 2020

My Data Diary

 

Day 1 (December 1st):

Today I decided to no longer use Google and to switch to a different browser that is more secure. The browser I have chosen is DuckDuckGo. The benefits of switching to DuckDuckGo are boundless. Everything from less propagated search queries to less of my data being sold.

 

Day 2 (December 2nd):

My next step in practicing counter surveillance is downloading and using a VPN. Today I installed NordVPN. By using a VPN, all of my internet use is now secure. This means that I am able to use the internet without the worry of my information being sold and my internet practices being under close scrutiny. There are also hidden benefits of downloading a VPN. I am also able to now watch Netflix shows that aren’t available in the United States, as well as watch videos that are banned in this country.

 

Day 3 (December 3rd)

Today I realized the importance of setting all of my social media to private and being careful of all of the information I share. Due to this I turned my instagram account to private and I turned off my location services on Snapchat, a service that allows other people to see your personal location.

 

Day 4 (December 4th):

This may sound simple but today I decided to cover up my webcam. With the presence of “always-on” programs such as Zoom, I find the extra safety precaution to be fairly necessary. And for the record, former FBI director James Comey said himself that Americans should cover their webcams.

 

https://thehill.com/policy/national-security/295933-fbi-director-cover-up-your-webcam

 

Day 5 (December 5th):

Now that it’s winter during the pandemic, I feel the most hidden in my entire life. When I wear my mask and a hoodie, I feel as if I have a blanket masking my identity. I think this will be my “get-up” for everytime I go out now.

 

Day 6 (December 6th):

Today I connected my Twitter account to applymagicsauce.com as a way to have some personal surveillance over myself, and while I have only tweeted a less than 50 times I was extremely surprised to see that the data profile that was created for me was insanely correct.

 

Day 7 (December 7th)

Today I decided that I would no longer fall into the trap of social media and I decided to stop using it entirely. As well I have decided to download all of my data in order to have personal agency over myself. Goodbye Instagram, Snapchat, and Twitter.

Counter Surveillance and Taking Agency Over Yourself

In the year 2020, humans have become subjugated to surveillance that is at a level that is completely unprecedented. By the means of social media, satellites, search engines, advertisements, and many other mediums, humanity has become surrounded by surveillance at every front. As well, privacy is dwindling down for the average person, more and more everyday, with very little chance of it ever returning to what it was. As each day passes, new algorithms are developed, with each one better than the last. These algorithms are designed in order to suck a person into the illusionary world of the surveillance state, making users more and more addicted to platforms that surveille them. It is no secret that these surveillance tactics have become incredibly detrimental to the mental health of humanity and due to this, counter-surveillance has become more important than it ever has been. Counter-surveillance is the actions that a person can put in place in order to take personal agency over how their data is being surveilled around the world and on the Internet. 

In order to take back agency over myself and my own personal surveillance, I decided that I would spend each day incorporating a new counter-surveillance method that would give me back freedom in the presence of a surveillance state. In chronological order these include, switching over search engines, using a Virtual Private Network, covering my web cameras and front facing mobile cameras, wearing surveillance-conscious clothing, analyzing my own social media data, and lastly getting rid of social media.

On the first day of my counter-surveillance experiment I decided to switch my search engine from Google to DuckDuckGO. Google is an incredibly infamous company due to their lack of privacy concerns, and is known to track users. From the Associated Press, “An Associated Press investigation found that many Google services on Android devices and iPhones store your location data even if you’ve used a privacy setting that says it will prevent Google from doing so.” DuckDuckGO, does none of this, at least according to them they don’t, and this alone does wonders from a counter-surveillance perspective. As well, Google is notorious in 2020 for heavily censoring search results for many different topics. In fact, I am still mesmerized by how different my experience on DuckDuckGo has been compared to Google.

Following this, on the second day, I started using a Virtual Private Network. Virtual Private Networks, also known as VPNs, disguise its users internet connection by rerouting it through a different location. During this process, the users browsing data becomes invisible to hackers, ISPs (Internet Service Providers), and even the government. The VPN that I chose to use is called NordVPN. NordVPN allows its users to choose a custom location that their virtual network is located in. This comes with many hidden benefits as well; Netflix shows and videos that are unavailable in the United States are accessible using a VPN. Instantly after using NordVPN, I feel more safe and secure.

The third step in my journey towards freedom from the surveillance state was to reassess all of my privacy related settings on social media. First I set all of my non-anonymous social media accounts to private, specifically Instagram and Facebook. This allows me to have direct control over who I allow to have agency over me. Following this I decided to go on Snapchat and edit all of my location services settings. Snapchat has a feature on its app that allows friends to see where other friends are located; while this is an amazing idea in concept, it is the antithesis to what counter-surveillance stands for. I changed the settings so that only my best friend and my girlfriend can see my location.

On the fourth day, I covered all of my webcams and front-facing mobile cameras. According to former FBI director James Comey, “If you go into any government office, we all have our little camera things that sit on top of the screen, they all have a little lid that closes down on them.” A lot of people find this to be silly, but in my personal opinion I believe that this is an obvious measure. This provides direct protection from the likes of hackers, the NSA, or whoever.  Another reason that I incorporated this into my own life was to give myself peace of mind. With the prevalence of free applications such as Snapchat and Zoom, I decided to take the FBI’s advice and put tape over my cameras.

Following this, on the fifth day, I decided to take the advice of surveillance conscious filmmaker Hito Steyl, and I made myself satellite proof. Due to the arrival of winter and the existence of the pandemic, this has become fairly easy. When I leave my house I wear a mask and a hoodie, as a result of this, all of my defining features are able to be disguised and invisible to satellites. According to Hito Steyl’s ironic short film “How To Not Be Seen,”  satellites have the ability to focus on any location in the world by a radius of only a couple feet. Due to this, I found it incredibly important to be more satellite-aware in my fashion choices.

On December 6th, I took direct action on created personal agency over myself and my own data. By using the website applymagicsauce.com, I was able to import my own social media data and create a data analysis sheet. The results shocked me, simply by looking at my posts and other social media activity, applymagicsauce.com was able to pinpoint nearly every single one of my personal intellectual characteristics. Honestly, this came to me as a shock and it took me a while to process all of this.

On the last day of my experiment, I decided to hang up the towel on Social Media. The six days prior to this, showcased the many reasons that I should stop falling for the illusion that social media provides. As a result, I deleted Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter from my phone. Of all the applications that I used in my experiment, I have found that this has given me the most freedom in the presence of the surveillance state.

In conclusion, this personal experiment allowed me to take back control in my own personal digital identity, and I would go as far as say that I feel free from the presence of the surveillance state. In the twenty-first century it is incredibly important for humanity to really think about what is more important: easability or freedom. Following my personal experiment, I discussed the implications with a group of four people who also attempted this on their own lives. After discussing with my group, I have found that we all took a very similar path to finding personal freedom; we all switched search engines, assessed our privacy settings, and started to cover our webcams. As a whole, we all found this to have an extremely positive outcome on our lives.

Works Cited

Steyl, Hito, director. How Not to Be Seen. A Fucking Didactic Educational .MOV File. Steyl, 2013.

“FBI Director Says He Covers His Webcam And Shares Other Security Recommendations”. Business Insider, 2020, https://www.businessinsider.com/fbi-director-covers-webcam-2016-9. Accessed 8 Dec 2020.

“The Importance Of Using A VPN – Stay Safe Online”. Stay Safe Online, 2016, https://staysafeonline.org/blog/the-importance-of-using-a-vpn/#:~:text=A%20virtual%20private%20network%20(VPN,your%20online%20security%20and%20privacy.&text=Additionally%2C%20because%20your%20data%20is,intercept%20your%20data%20en%20route. Accessed 8 Dec 2020.

 

The Surveillance Project

Digital Diary:

  • Thursday, November 26, 2020
      • This day was thanksgiving day! I really didn’t go out into a public place where they have cameras all over the place, but I did end up going to my cousin’s house for dinner. Her property is not that big but she does have security cameras around her house. These cameras are activated once a person approaches her house.
  • Friday, November 27, 2020
      • The day after thanksgiving was Black Friday, the craziest time of the year! I work at the Columbiana Center, Hollister to be exact and when you first walk into the mall, there are cameras right above your head. There is also a screen where you can see yourself.
  • Sunday, November 29, 2020
      • It is Sunday morning and my family and I are getting ready for church. The church I go to is located in downtown Columbia, right beside Finlay park. Now my church has cameras inside and out. You can spot the ones inside the church very easily but for some reason I can’t seem to find the ones that are outside. You can then see all the cameras that are being used on the monitor that is right behind the desk. After church I went to work and I walked right passed the same camera from last time.
  • Tuesday, December 1, 2020
      • It’s the beginning of a new month and it’s also the last month of the year! So today I have a shift from 4-9. So I get ready for work and when I arrive, I walk through those same doors like always and pass those same cameras as well. This time I’m taking a closer look at the store and try to locate our security cameras, for some reason I can’t seem to find them but I know they are there.  
  • Wednesday, December 2, 2020
      • Today is another beautiful day. My shift today is from 11:30-4:30. As usual, I arrive at my destination and I walk through the same door again and as i’m walking in I can see myself on the monitor from the camera that’s right about the door when you first walk in.
  • Thursday, December 3, 2020
      • It’s Thursday! It’s almost the end of the week and my last day of work and I will have the weekend to myself with no cameras around. So today my shift is from 1-5. At this point you’re probably getting tired of me explaining how I walk through the same door and passing by the same cameras. This time I paid closer attention to our stock room. In the stock room there is only one camera and it’s right in the middle of the ceiling but it’s monitoring the whole room. 
  • Monday, December 7, 2020
      • It’s Monday and it’s also the last day of my diary entry. My shift today was from 12-5. And yes I walked through the same doors and saw the same cameras. But today I was working in the stockroom doing shipment and I was being watched by that one camera the whole time.

 

Surveillance Project:

Have you ever been paranoid because you felt like someone was watching you? Well I have, but I never thought we were being watched all the time and without was even knowing. No matter where I go or where I walk into, someone can see every move I make. Have I scared you yet? Don’t worry i’m also scared. Wherever we go we always see some kind of video and closed circuit television (CCTV). Whenever we see any kind of surveillance we might think, “oh they probably can’t see us,” or “who’s watching us?” We may ask these questions to ourselves, but in reality they are watching us. These CCTV’s could be beneficial in some ways and maybe not so beneficial. I will try my best to navigate through my local areas and demonstrate if these CCTV surveillance cameras are beneficial to have or are they just there because.

I would always go shopping or to work without worrying about who might be watching me. I knew there were cameras everywhere but I never knew it would be something I would pay attention to now when I go out somewhere. When you first walk into the Columbiana Center, using any of the entrance doors, there is a black dome camera above the door. When the camera gets activated, you will appear on the monitor. I never understood why they have these cameras on the doors since they really don’t do anything but I would say it would be safe to put them there. The reason would be because if someone tries to do harm to the other people that’s in the mall, we would be able to see where that person came from and what that person could be wearing. In the store Hollister, where I work, our cameras are not visible. The type of cameras we have are also the black dome cameras. Since many people think we don’t have cameras, they think it’s easy for them to steal. It’s beneficial for us to have these because we will know what people are shoplifting but the bad thing is that we personally cannot see them. We would have to call the head manager to pull those videos up. Also we don’t have cameras where our jean walls are because all of our jeans have sensors on them and if someone tries to steal them then the sensor detector can go off. Our fitting rooms are for privacy so we don’t have any installed in there.

In my diary documentation, you can see there are three pictures of the same camera. I would consider these the outside camera. These three cameras are set up around my cousin’s house and my uncle is the one that can see everything that’s being monitored. The purpose of the CCTV selected space  is that one of the cameras detects who is at their door and it will inform my uncle through his phone. One of the other ones is facing in their backyard just in case  someone comes into their property and the one that’s on the light post, that one is facing my cousin’s window. As a joke he said that he installed that one to keep a close eye on her but in reality he installed it just in case someone arrives in his driveway. The main reason he installed them is for the security of his home and to prevent his things from getting stolen.it will make him and his family feel much safer.

The last location I was around on Sundays was my church. My church is located in downtown Columbia and it is also beside Finlay park. I can say out of all the locations I was around, my church has to be the one that has many CCTV cameras around the building. The CCTV cameras they use are also the outdoor cameras and the regular dome cameras inside. On the outside the things that are being monitored is the main entrance, the court year where the fountain is, the playground, the children school and the back of the church. The main reason the whole outside is monitored is for the safety of the adults and the children. Also because in front of the church, there is a homeless shelter and as we know in downtown there are many homeless people walking around and also Finlay park is not like how it used to be where kids can run around and have fun. Now it’s invaded with homeless people. Another reason is because some of the homeless likes to sleep on the church property and they just don’t want to risk anyone who comes on their property to get harm. Plus, since children come to school during the week they want to make sure the kids are always okay. Since the inside of the church also has cameras you can see everything. I’m guessing it has so many cameras because it’s a very strict and organized place. They wouldn’t want the people who’re working to get hurt by someone. 

There are many reasons why some places install cameras around their stores, homes, or their building. Me personally is beneficial because it’s for their security and keeping things from happening. I think all the data they get from these cameras can really show them what’s going on around their surroundings and in case of an emergency they can show that clip whenever it happens. It’s kind of bad how we don’t have cameras around our jean walls in the store because some people can pop the sensors of the clothes and they can also steal things from us like that, and yes it has happened before. One of my colleagues was on a military base and she said that she did the security measures and she saw how different they were. She found that it is more intrusive and less unavoidable than the CCTV in other places.

In conclusion, surveillance is going to keep improving as life goes on. We can’t hide from it nor we can run. Wherever we go we will always be watched no matter how sneaky we think we are. So are you scared to go out or do you find it normal?

The Quantified Self

Day 1

Today was my first day back at home. Already, my watch connected to the GPS signals and could tell where I was. Apparently, I slept well in my bed at home. This image is a screenshot from the Garmin App. Today I discovered it tracks your movement every hour. I find that really creepy, and it is not something they advertise. I think it is good to bring awareness to the fact technology can do things you are unaware of. 

Day 2

This is my second day back home. The data is very similar from yesterday. However, I ran in a different place. To protect your privacy, Garmin only records the county you run in. However, one can still see exactly where you run through the app. I think this feature may give users a false sense of security. The constant monitoring of my heart rate throughout the day is starting to creep me out. 

Day 3

Today my resting heart rate was lower which is good, but I think it’s because I ran less. I like that the app can help me improve my recovery with the heart rate feature. One way you can take back technology is by not wearing or using it. I took my watch off to charge and I like that there is no recorded data.

Day 4

A cool thing I discovered today were the seasonal themed challenges on the app. I think that is fun and enticing. One thing that irritates me with the app is how slow it is to connect and upload data from my watch. I think it may be because of the amount of data my watch holds, which is again, creepy. 

Day 5

I am starting to get freaked out about the steps and timing the app constantly records. By looking at this data, someone could find out when I am not home and rob my house. It is hard to weigh out the good and the bad with surveillance. 

Day 6

Yesterday I went up to visit my friend in Pittsburgh so that threw off my sleep and running schedules. It may be good to have that variety so no one can constantly track you. A good privacy feature of the app is that unless I record an activity, it doesn’t display location. From this data, you can not tell I left home. 

Day 7

Today was an interesting day. My watch did not connect to my phone’s bluetooth so a lot of the data is missing. I like that this is another way to control my data. Additionally, you can see I ran in a different area than usual. This is interesting because Herndon is a part of Fairfax County so the data is seemingly randomly more precise.

Quantified Self Reflection

My project followed my daily activities. I utilized a Garmin Forerunner watch (worn 24/7) as well as the Garmin Connect app. Initially, I tried to use the app Instant, but I found it far too invasive upon my data. Through the Garmin Connect app, I was able to gather data such as sleep, steps, activities, and heart rate. The data was displayed as totals as well as broken down hourly. Each day I synced my watch and took a screenshot of the previous day’s data. I reflected upon the data in my Data Diary. Tracking my daily data raised questions of privacy for me. 

The quantified self is a relatively new term. It refers to self- knowledge through self- tracking (Quantified Self Institute). Due to technology innovations, many aspects of our lives can now be tracked, like sleep and heart rate. The quantified self creates a data double- you, but in data and numbers form. There are both positives and negatives to the quantified self. Positively, the quantified self allows for better health data. However, there are also many negatives. In Kathrin Rogella’s We Never Sleep the quantified self was created and the physical self faded away. The quantified self can take away joys in life. Additionally, the quantified self can allow for major governmental control, as seen in Juli Zeh’s The Method. The quantified self dehumanizes us. It is important to find value in the data, and not just let it take over our lives. 

I utilized the Garmin Connect app to monitor my heart rate, activities, steps (including  stairs), and activities such as recorded runs and walks. This data is useful to me as I am a runner and I like to look at my statistics to find ways to improve. The self observation also allowed me to think about privacy and security in relation to the app. I wanted to find out how much data would be available to others. It was also interesting to track my heart rate. It gave me insights to when I was stressed and when I was calm. Data like I collected allows me to have a better sense of self and change my habits. For example, if I notice I usually get stressed and my heart rate raises at a certain time, I can perform meditation or another stress relieving activity during that time period. Another aspect I get from my heart rate relates to my training. When my heart rate is over 180bpm, I know that I am pushing myself very hard. If it gets to near 200, I know I need to slow down or take a break. Personal data can be useful for many things in life. 

The Garmin Connect app allows for a great creation of the quantified self. It is great for measuring values such as heart rate and sleep. It can even monitor your sleep cycles and analyze them for you. The app is great for connecting with other Garmin users. Your personal data is somewhat protected. It will disguise your activities by placing them in the broader category of county. However, it is still possible to discover one’s location. Another benefit of the app is the user privacy settings. One’s profile, activities and badges have the option to be visible to everyone, only friends, only friends and groups, or only oneself. A worry is the default setting is set to everyone. 

My data is shared only with my friends on the app and Garmin itself. One concern I have is that my data may have been compromised when Garmin was hacked in July. The benefits of the app are that it allows me to connect with other users. I like to compete through the app with my uncle, who lives in another country. Another benefit is the choice in privacy settings. I also enjoy being able to monitor my daily progress such as steps and set step goals. The sleep feature is very useful for determining if I am well rested. Some drawbacks of the app are the minimal users of it. Another disadvantage is the outdated software. The app is very slow and the formatting is outdated. It could do with a major update as it has been the same for five years. Overall, I feel like my data is as secure as it can be for being on the internet. 

In The Method, the citizens in the society all have a tracker. The main character, Mia has a chip “in the same place as everyone else’s, in the middle of the bicep” (Zeh 58). In a way, society has progressed to this today. Between smartwatches and smartphones, we are all being monitored constantly. In the news, you hear people worried about the COVID- 19 vaccine. They believe there will be “a chip to track people” (Tregde). It is strange people have not recognized we are already being constantly monitored. A great thing about this class is how it has drawn my attention to this. Additionally, the class has given me ways to reduce the surveillance on myself. I think those that are worried about the vaccine need to do more research into their devices and apps to realize they are already constantly tracked. The chip is self- implanted. The chip for the vaccines is not for government use and is located on the outside of the syringe. This way, “healthcare workers will have the option to tag it with their phone. That will allow them to upload a date, time and GPS location of each vaccination in real-time” (Tregde). The common theme is surveillance, whether it’s of you or a vaccine. 

In our group, we discussed the different apps we used to collect data. Some of us used sleep apps, and some of us used the Apple Health app. The Health app and the Garmin Connect app are very similar. They both get the best data from having a compatible watch. One thing that stuck out to me in our conversations was how surprised we all were with how in depth statistics were measured. Ella talked about how her Health app tracked her speed when climbing stairs. It can be concerning how much data is being constantly collected. Other statistics like phone/ screen time usage allowed us to see how much of our life we are on devices. However, it is not all encompassing as laptop and TV time don’t get recorded. A benefit to using the watches is for us to record activities. I think that it helps me to stay more active, and I feel like people in my group would also agree. 

Works Cited

Quantified Self Institute. “What is Quantified Self?” Quantified Self Institute, http://qsinstitute.com/about/what-is-quantified-self/. Accessed 2 December 2020.

Tregde, David. “Verify: COVID-19 vaccine syringes to have trackers on the outside, not in vaccine.” WUSA9, 16 July 2020, VERIFY: COVID-19 vaccine syringes to have trackers on the outside, not in vaccine. Accessed 7 December 2020.

Zeh, Juli. The Method. Harvill Secker, 2012.

Final Surveillance Project: The Quantified Self

Data Diary

  • Wednesday, November 25:
    • I went into bed at 1:39 AM and was in bed for 5 hours and 42 minutes. I fell asleep for 5 hours and 31 minutes. I had 5 disturbances while I was asleep, but my sleep efficiency was 97%. I woke up at 7:21 AM and my respiratory rate was 18.8. I was a little tired, I definitely could have slept more.
  • Thursday, November 26:
    • I was in bed for 7 hours and 16 minutes and I went to bed at 2:26 in the morning and fell asleep at 2:39. I had 12 disturbances throughout the night and woke up at 9:55, having 6 hours and 44 minutes of sleep with a respiratory rate of 18.6. I slept pretty well besides the disturbances.
  • Friday, November 27:
    • I slept from 5:53 AM to 12:30 with a total of 6 hours and 28 minutes of sleep, but I was in bed for 6 hours and 28 minutes.I had 7 disturbances. My respiratory rate was 19.3. My performance throughout the day definitely suffered from my lack of sleep during the night.
  • Saturday, November 28:
    • I was in bed for 8 hours and 5 minutes and I fell asleep at 3:45 in the morning. I slept for 7 hours and 21 minutes until I woke up at 11:51 AM. I had heightened physical and mental energy from my 7 hours and 21 minutes of sleep. My overall performance from the day improved my extended sleep.
  • Sunday, November 29:
    • I was in bed for 6 hours and 44 minutes. I slept for 6 hours and 5 minutes from 2:54 in the morning to 9:39 in the morning. I had 6 disturbances throughout the night and my sleep efficiency was at 90%. My respiratory rate was at 19.2. I felt like I slept pretty well tonight.
  • Monday, November 30:
    • Although I was in bed for 8 hours, I was awake for about 40 minutes before I fell asleep at 3:02 AM. I woke up at 11:08 AM, for a total of 7 hours and 19 minutes of sleep. I got 75% of the sleep that I need with 91% efficiency but I had 7 disturbances. This was the best night of sleep I got.
  • Tuesday, December 1:
    • I was in bed for 3 hours and 59 minutes and asleep for 3 hours and 1 minute. I went to sleep at 3:01 AM and woke up at 7:03 AM. I had 5 disturbances, my sleep efficiency was 76% and my respiratory rate was 18.9. Getting only 3 hours of sleep increased my injury for the following day.

Reflection

To quantify, by definition means, “to determine, express, or measure the quantity of,” and self, by definition means, “an individual’s typical character or behavior.” A quantified self is self-knowledge through self-tracking. We are all being surveilled, whether it be by walking past a street camera, or using a credit card at a store, or tracking yourself while sleeping. Despite the fact that it may be scary or just weird to know that we are constantly being surveilled and tracked, it is not always bad. We need this surveillance to know the truth. To know what is actually happening in our lives and how it is affecting us. We rely on this information as a society to live and function the best way we can. To prove this, I used a tracking device called WHOOP, to track my sleeping patterns and how it affected my everyday life.

WHOOP tracks your physical activity, sleeping habits, blood pressure, breathing rate, heart rate, digestion, and more. All my information from the watch was immediately transferred to an app on my phone where I can check all my statistics. The watch is nice because it does not only track how long you sleep for or when you were in the deepest part of your sleep, it uses all your vitals during your sleep to compare how it affected you the next day. It also shows how what you did during the day affects your sleep. With this information I am able to determine exactly why I was not at peak physical ability during the day and what to do to make sure I am the next day. For example, on Friday, November 27, I did not sleep enough and the app told me, “You only got 5:53 of the 9:59 you needed. Performance suffered as a result,” and then proceeded to tell me all about my vitals from when I was sleeping. The next night I slept more and so my performance improved. I need this to improve on my daily life and to make sure my body is staying healthy.

Some sleep tracking apps that I have used in the past only require you to put your phone close to you while sleeping and from there, it documents your sleep. The WHOOP watch is different because it is not close to you, it is on you. It is the closest you can get to a tracking device, without implanting some sort of chip. “The WHOOP Strap 3.0 collects physiological data 24/7 to provide the most accurate and granular understanding of your body.” Although, in Juli Zeh’s, The Method, citizens do have to have a chip implanted in their arm to be tracked and to optimize the citizens’ health and daily life. The citizens are constantly being tracked, every second of every day of their life. Why were the citizens in The Method constantly being tracked? The same reason that we track ourselves, to optimize our health and ultimately, our lives. Juli Zeh agrees that, “Health is a state of complete physical, spiritual and social well being – and not the mere absence of disease,”(Zeh 1). It is scary to think of a world where we are forced to give our health information by a chip in our arm, but really it is necessary to track these aspects of our life. “Science tells us that you don’t get stronger in the gym (that’s what breaks you down), you actually get stronger during rest. Sleep can be the forgotten third of your life. It’s the period to repair, regenerate and prime your mind and body for peak performance. WHOOP measures not only how long you sleep, but the time spent in each stage to better understand sleep quality. The WHOOP Sleep Coach tells you exactly how much sleep you need to reach your desired performance level the next day.” Maybe it should not be a chip in our arm, but with an app like WHOOP or any tracking app, it is important to better our health and lives. 

As a result of WHOOP not just being an app on the app store, and it being a watch, you do have to pay for it. Though, the app comes free with the purchase of the watch. Being that the app records so much, there are some limitations, like the cardiovascular load. WHOOP announced that, “WHOOP Strain, reported on a scale from zero to 21, measures the total cardiovascular load experienced over a specified period of time – such as a workout or day – normalized such that a 21.0 represents the maximal cardiovascular load that could be attained in a day.” So really, the max for the cardiovascular load is the healthy amount you should be using a day. There are some more memberships you can sign up for different accesses to information, but the sleeping tracking portion is free.

In Kathrin Roeggla’s, We Never Sleep, citizens are in a constant state of pressure to work a twenty-four hour work cycle. Taking a break or breather is very much looked down upon, it is actually credited when one goes days or weeks without sleep. The value of these people’s whole lives are changed because of why they are being tracked. So in We Never Sleep, the people are praised for their lack of sleep and recognized as a bad worker when they do sleep; their constant tracking affects everything they do. “She wanted to stay in touch with herself, in fact, immediately… she had no regrets, she wasn’t sorry she wasn’t there anymore,”(Roeggla 8).I think that this book brings out some unfortunate situations in the world that we live in. There are some careers that carry so much work and it is expected that the employees never stop doing it, because when they do, they fall behind and someone else can take their position. In that case, I think that the book brings out an exaggerated mental and physical problem in the workplace. Nevertheless, We Never Sleep, in a darker way, shows how important it is to track sleep and help. Sleep is so necessary and tracking how we sleep is just as crucial. 

Not all students in my group tracked their sleep, but the ones that did had a very similar approach. We agreed that tracking sleep is so important for everyday lives and health. Other students in the group were still in agreement that a lot of data was tracked and that it is actually pretty important to know what is being tracked. 

As a society and as a person, we rely on our sleep information to live the best life we can and to stay as healthy as we can. The quantified self has proven through many different ways of tracking, that we are living in a world of surveillance. Technology has allowed us to prevail and better ourselves as a society. If everybody embraced the technological world we are living in and used these resources to help ourselves and everyone else, society as a whole could have the potential to become great. Looking at We Never Sleep and The Method, we are able to compare them to the world that we live in and see just how important and useful self tracking our sleep is in our world today. We have the chance to better ourselves in every way, why not take it? 

Works Cited:

Labs, DI. “The World’s Most Powerful Fitness Membership.” WHOOP, 2 Dec. 2020, www.whoop.com/?gclid=CjwKCAiAwrf-BRA9EiwAUWwKXky5drRFVvkuQ0iHRNKZ6-MVjKk_0c5JfpO2wMPBjsipe_4E1OAY_xoCfKQQAvD_BwE. 

“Self.” Merriam-Webster, Merriam-Webster, www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/quantified. 

“Quantified.” Merriam-Webster, Merriam-Webster, www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/quantified. 

Röggla, Kathrin, et al. We Never Sleep. Ariadne Press, 2009. 

 Zeh, Juli, and Sally-Ann Spencer. The Method. Vintage Books, 2014.

 

The Quantified Self

Surveillance Project Diary :

11 / 30 – Monday :
Today I burned 505 calories. I exercised for 18 minutes by walking my dog luna and walked 9,372 steps. I climbed nine flights of stairs by going upstairs to my bedroom. I found a new element that my apple watch tracks. My apple watch tracks how fast I go up the stairs. Today I walked up the stairs at a range of 1.3-1.9 ft /s. I stood up for at least one minute for 15 hours. I also walked approximately 4.3 miles. My heart rate range was from 72-84 BPM. The sound levels around me ranged from 36 – 81 dB. Today was a pretty active day for me, although I could not work out as much as I would like. Beginning this project, I cannot help but weigh the positives and negatives of allowing others or the government to have access to my health data. Like Mia in Juli Zeh’s The Method, I find myself more reluctant to allow the government to use my health data for “research purposes” because I am not optimistic that that is really what it is being used for.

12 / 1 – Tuesday :
Today I found many new features on my apple watch: resting calories, the time I stood, resting heart rate, step length, and walking speed. Many of these features that I discovered today reminded me of new surveillance and how, in our modern age, we can have items such as apple watches that work with our senses and cognition. I burned 461 calories and burned 1,422 resting calories. I exercised for 21 minutes and walked approximately 4.1 miles. I also completed 8,954 steps. I stood up at least one minute for 15 hours and stood for a total of 125 minutes. I had three classes, which is why I did not stand up much throughout the day. My environmental sound levels ranged from 32 – 102 dB. My heart rate range was from 62 – 149 BPM with a peak of 149 at 4-5 pm, probably because my mom told me dinner was ready, and I got excited. My resting heart rate was 80 BPM, and my walking heart rate was 119 BPM. My step length was 26.4 inches, which surprised me a lot since I am 5’2. My walking speed was 3.1 mph and how fast I walked up the stairs was 1.6 ft /s. Today I was less active than yesterday, but considering I have three classes on Tuesdays, I feel as though I was productive

12/2 – Wednesday:
Today my apple watch tracked that I burned a total of 401 calories. It showed that I exercised for 16 minutes and stood for one minute in 14 hours. I took a total of 7,159 steps and walked for around 3.2 miles. In total, I stood for 120 minutes along with climbing 12 floors. I had 1,426 resting calories, my average heart rate at about 111 beats per minute. My environmentally sound levels were similar to the day before, being at 32-93 dB. My resting heart rate averaged 71 BPM. With my step length being 18.9-29.1 inches, my daily speed ranged between 1.9-3.7 mph. Today I checked my settings to see where all of my data was going. I was happy to find out that I do not allow my data off my apple watch to be shared with other apps or used for research purposes. I feel as though only seeing myself through my Apple watch’s eyes that I often caught myself appearing as just a number in a system, which made me feel a bit odd since my apple watch is supposed to be personalized to me.

12/3 – Thursday :
Today I burned 401 calories and burned a total of 1,477 resting calories. I exercised for 16 minutes, which is lower than usual. I traveled 3.2 miles and completed a total of 7,197 steps. I stood up for at least one minute for 15 hours and stood for 90 minutes. I was not happy at the amount of time I was sitting today, but I guess that’s what comes with all of my online classes. I climbed 14 flights of stairs. Today I noted that my watch calculated both my speed going up and down the stairs. My rate down the stairs ranged from 1.1 – 1.6 ft/s while my pace up the stairs was 1.6 ft /s. My environmental sound levels ranged from 32 – 95 dB. My heart rate went from 54 – 144 BPM with a resting heart rate of 68 BPM. My walking heart rate was 68 BPM, considering I barely walked today, and my walking speed was very slow at 1.6 – 3.2 mph. My step length was 18.5 – 28. 7 inches. Today was not a very active day, but it probably means I was super studious. Throughout the day, I was reminded of how surveillance is an exercise of power and how when we are surveilling ourselves, we often take away the control that the government has over us as Hasan M. Elahi did his “Tracking Transience” throughout his day through pictures.

12/4 – Friday :
Today my apple watch tracked that I burned 456 calories and had a total of 1,490 resting calories. I exercised for 30 minutes and was pretty active, and traveled 3.9 miles. I took 8,769 steps and stood up one minute in 14 hours, and stood for 113 minutes. My heart rate ranged from 61 – 151 BPM and rested at approximately 79 BPM. My walking heart rate was 113 BPM. Today I climbed 19 flights of stairs, and my speed up the stairs was 0.92 – 1.6 ft /s, which was lower than usual, and my pace down the stairs was 1.2 ft /s. My environmental sound levels stayed approximately the same as it has been for the past couple of days at 32 – 93 dB. I found another new feature on my watch that calculated how far I walked in six minutes, and it said in six minutes I walked 500m. My walking speed averaged 1.4 – 3.6 mph, and my step length was approximately 16.9 – 31.9 inches, which was larger than usual. Overall, it appeared that I had a pretty active day.

12/5 – Saturday :
For Saturday, I burned a total of 438 calories while exercising for 22 minutes. I took a total of 7,201 steps, totally out to be around 3.3 miles. I had 1,498 resting calories with my resting heart rate at 71 beats per minute. I stood for a total of 102 minutes and climbed ten flights of stairs with my stair speed up being between .85-1.3 feet per second and my stair speed down being 1.9 feet per second. My stair speed up was a little slower than usual. My environmental sound levels were 32-107 dB, and my heart rate ranged between 66-147 beats per minute. My walking speed ranged between 2.1- 4.2 mph, being the fact that I went out with friends and walked around town. My step length for the day was considerably longer than usual, between 19.7-35.8 inches, slightly raising my average walking heart rate to 118 beats per minute. Overall, I had an eventful day but am super excited to head into the last week of school and be done.

12/6 – Sunday :
Today was a great day because I am finally done recording myself, I’m just kidding. It was a great day because I went Christmas shopping for my mom. I burned a total of 426 calories and burned a total of 1,376 resting calories. I walked 4 miles and completed 16 minutes of exercise. I met 8,917 steps, and my step length was 26 inches. I stood up at least one minute for 13 hours but stood up for a total of 129 minutes. I climbed nine floors, and my speed up the stairs was 1.4 ft/s, and my pace down the stairs was 1.3 ft/s. My heart rate was 96 BPM when I collected this data and varied 24 ms. My resting heart rate was 76 BPM, and my walking heart rate was 120 BPM. My walking speed was 2.4 mph. My environmental sound levels were 38 – 110 dB, with a peak of 110 at 9-10 pm, possibly due to my dog barking. Today I found a new feature called walking asymmetry. Walking asymmetry is used to see how well you’re walking by taking both the left and right sides of your body. My walking asymmetry was 3.4 %, and I believe that healthy walking asymmetry is 5 %, so I need to do better walking evenly. After collecting data for a week on myself, I have realized that if I do not complete specific goals such as exercising each day, I often feel inadequate and let that get into my head. Users need to realize that your data does not define you as a person and your identity.

 

Reflection :
In recent years, Apple came out with its first Apple Watch. The Apple Watch can track your exercise, heart rate, environmental sound levels, and much more. Like myself, many people were fascinated by the Apple Watch and its capabilities and purchased the watch. For a week, I tracked my activity through my Apple Watch to explore my data that the watch was tracking. Throughout the week, I found many new features on my watch that I didn’t know existed and played with my settings to see who was accessing the data from my watch.

There are many elements of our lives that we monitor. From our heart rate, running pace, sleep patterns, or step count, we are continually surveillancing ourselves. According to Live Science, the quantified self refers to the “increasing use of technology to collect data about oneself” (Rettner). Through this project, I understood private versus public information and the importance of being aware of who is accessing data that you plan to keep secret. I was also able to know how through surveillancing yourself, you often take away the power that the government has over you as Hasan M. Elahi did in his “Tracking Transcience” through always documenting elements of his life like the food he ate, flights he was on, and much more. Through this, Elahi was able to take power away from the government and back to himself. In many ways, throughout the week, I felt that surveillancing myself allowed me to feel like I was in charge of my data. As I explored my Apple Watch, I was made aware of many aspects of my watch that would be considered new surveillance and how these new technologies could be beneficial to us and harmful at the same time.

On my Apple Watch, I mainly measured my activity throughout the day, including calories burned, how long I stood up, how many steps I took, my heart rate, and much more. I chose to measure this because I was interested to see how my activity changed over the week and to see what factors in my life played into my mobility and movement. For example, on Tuesdays and Thursdays, I would often note that I had significantly fewer minutes that I stood. I concluded that this was more than likely because I have three classes on both Tuesdays and Thursdays. Therefore I am less active on those days of the week.
My observation of myself was to understand my Apple Watch and understand where my data is going. Before beginning this experiment, I did not know many of the features of my Apple watch. For example, I was unaware of the element that measures my Environmental Sound Levels and how that, in a way, means that my Apple Watch is listening to everything that is going on around me. On the second day of my experiment, I checked my settings to see where my data collected from my watch was going. I was relieved to find out that my settings were that I did not allow any other apps to access my data, and I did not allow for my data to be used for research purposes.

The knowledge that I planned to gain throughout the experiment was seeing what patterns my activity took over the week and what similarities I could draw from day to day. I also planned to gain knowledge from Apple by seeing how accurate I felt the data collected. In some instances, I often would move my arm that my watch was on, and it would count that movement as me exercising when I was not. I will go into more detail about this later.

The data my watch collected was generally valuable to me. In some instances, I felt as though some data was more useful than others. For example, my step count was less helpful because it is merely just a number, in my opinion. The data that was more valuable to me featured such as my heart rate and my data patterns over a period of time because that data is much more personal to me and, in my opinion, is my private data. I know that I found myself feeling like a statistic rather than a real human being in many cases, but I was also aware of the importance of protecting what I felt was my private data.
Overall, I was pretty satisfied with the data that my Apple Watch collected. I enjoyed exploring all of the different features that the watch had to offer and was amazed at just how advanced the technology was from a small item. As I stated above, my data was not shared with any other apps or used for research purposes, but I imagine that Apple may use the data without telling us, which would not surprise me. Throughout the week, I contemplated the benefits and the negatives of using the Apple Watch. Many of the services I found were that you could track an array of elements of your life and set daily goals for yourself. For example, my everyday goal is to burn 400 calories, and that goal motivates me to be active throughout my day. In many instances, I was reminded of a specific quote from Juli Zeh’s The Method. Zeh states, “The Method was developed so that every individual can enjoy maximum longevity and minimal biological dysfunction – or put simply, a happy and healthy life, a life free from suffering and pain” (29). Although there are many benefits to having the data readily available to us, we run the risk of becoming addicted to the data and getting too wrapped up in our data, and allowing it to affect our mental health. I often find myself getting upset when I do not exercise enough and find that affecting my mental health, and that is something that needs to be considered when collecting all of this data about ourselves.

Although I used my Apple Watch, other group members utilized apps that tracked their sleep or tracked their speed while driving. I found that interesting because we all chose different apps that displayed that there is so much potential data that could be collected under the quantified self. In general, I believe that most of the group was shocked at the amount of possible data our electronic devices could collect without us even being aware of it. Overall, through this project, I gained a better understanding of private versus public data, the mental health risk of this data, and just the amount of data collected on us. Through this experiment, I felt as though I realized just how powerful surveillance is and how often those who surveillance others often possess power over whom they are surveilling. The aspect of control regarding surveillance is essential and is something that we need to look out for as our world continues to progress and increase its technology.

Works Cited
Elahi, Hasan M. Tracking Transience v2.2, elahi.gmu.edu/track/.
Rettner, Rachael. What Is the Quantified Self? 26 Aug. 2013,
www.livescience.com/39185-quantified-self-movement.html.
Zeh, Juli, and Sally-Ann Spencer. The Method. Vintage Books, 2014.

Life 360

*Note: this data is from a full week. The first photo shows overall data and the next three show individual data for each day

 

Data Diary:

Monday: On Monday November 30, my friends and I spent lots of time on our phones collectively. Combined, we spent over 10 hours using our phones. While it doesn’t show a specific value after 10 for each day, the weekly hour number was 248. If you divide this by 7 days and then by 9 people we each averaged around 4 hours a day on phones. Next, we only had 2 hard breakings but no rapid accelerations for that day, which is pretty low!

Tuesday: On Tuesday December 1, we again each spent around 4 hours plus on our cell phones. After looking at my screen time, it is clear that I actually went above that time period for most days so taking the average of my friends was not as accurate. We also had 4 (which is the maximum for the week) hard breakings and 2 rapid accelerations.

Wednesday: On Wednesday December 2, we all averaged around 4 hours on our phones. After looking at my screen time, it was clear that I actually averaged closer to 8 hours! We also hit the maximum amount of hard breaking (4) and had a maximum of 3 rapid accelerations.

Thursday: On Thursday December 3, the phone average was the same but I spent 7.5 hours on my phone that day. We had 3 hard breakings and only 1 rapid acceleration.

Friday: On Friday December 4, the phone average was again 4 hours but I spent 7.25 hours on my phone. We had 1 hard breaking and no accelerations. This was the day that most of our group started to quarantine. My friend Riley got COVID so all of my friends began the process of quarantining and getting tested.

Saturday: On Saturday December 5, the phone average was again 4 hours but I spent 5 hours on my phone. We had no hard breakings or rapid accelerations; this is probably because no one was driving since all of my friends were quarantining.

Sunday: On Sunday December 6, the phone average was the same but I spent 7 hours on my phone. After talking to my friends, I learned that each of them all spent above 4 hours on their phones from Friday to Sunday, most likely due to isolation and boredom. We also had no hard breakings or rapid accelerations because no one left their house.

 

Reflection

My data diary consists of the data collected from Life 360 within the past week. The term quantified self is defined as “the act of using personal data to improve one’s quality of life” (Investopedia). In today’s technology driven world, our data is tracked in about everything we do whether we know it or not. Among studying and listening to the first episode of “The Privacy Paradox”, it was apparent that our data is extremely useful for large corporations. Many think that their collected data is being given to the government in order to track us and spy on us, when in reality it is actually being sold to companies for a lot of money. Companies use our personal data to improve their products and learn how to advertise them better. For example, our phones use their microphone to listen to us talking in our free time. They will then use that data to formulate personalized ads for products we may have talked about. While this may be nice for easy access, it is an invasion of privacy and should not be permitted. 

I would like to explain my data a little more before I analyze its purpose and dangers. My friends and I have an online group on the app Life 360. Life 360 is an app created for parents that allows them to track their child through their cell phone. The app allows parents to view location at all times, phone battery, driving speed, and much more. In my data shown, I collected the driving reports of my friends for the past week. The first photo shows the average stats for the week, including total miles driven, top speed of the week, and how many drives we collectively had. Each photo after this shows the detail for each day  for the past 7 days in each category. For example, you can see that there were 4 “hard brakes” while driving on Tuesday. I chose to measure the data from this app because I feel that it is the most intrusive. I have the app for fun with my friends so we can see where each of us are but I wanted to take a closer look at it. While it is a nice safety feature for teenage girls living in a major city on their own, I often wonder if it is worth it to have. The means by which it tracks you is quite creepy to me. The goal of my self observation is to determine whether Life 360 is a safe app and also to figure out where our data goes. The data on the app is very valuable to me as it shows where I live, how I drive and where my friends live as well. 

Next, I would like to analyze the actual app and try to figure out where my data goes. After reading reviews on the app, it is safe to say that it is not favorable by any means. Many people have reported that the app actually shows them in a different place than they actually are. One of the reviews was a man saying that the app is responsible for his divorce; it said he was somewhere he was not and his wife assumed he was cheating. I find this review really funny but in reality, it can actually complicate and harm families. I also found something that is making me delete the entire app for good; Life 360 actually sells your data to companies. Not only are your locations and statistics sold, but your driving record is sold to insurance companies. Many people have deleted the app because their insurance rate has gone up because of the app. The app tracks your top speed, how many fast accelerations and hard brakes you have, and also detects crashes. People are getting charged for their driving habits without their knowledge because of Life 360. What started out as a fun app for me and my friends turned into something quite harmful to me which I will be deleting. 

This app reminds me of the telescreens in George Orwell’s “1984”. The telescreens that track the citizens of Oceania follow their every move without their knowledge; it even tracks their thoughts. Orwell states “The telescreen received and transmitted simultaneously. Any sound that Winston made, above the level of a very low whisper, would be picked up by it; moreover, so long as he remained within the field of vision which the metal plaque commanded, he could be seen as well as heard. There was of course no way of knowing whether you were being watched at any given moment” (Orwell 66). Like the telescreens, Life 360 has no way of shutting off unless you delete it. Like I said, my friends and I have the app for fun but the most common use of the app is for parents to track their children, in which the kids have no way of turning it off without their parents knowledge. While this app is a great safety feature, it is completely unfair and an invasion of personal data and I think it should be banned from selling information to insurance companies. 

Lastly, I would like to address my group members data recorded. I remember that Ella was going to use her Apple Watch to track her physical activity over the last week. After looking into the Apple Watch, it is clear that Apple promises that customer health data won’t be sold out to third party companies. I think that the watch is a great way of staying fit and will help a lot of people track their fitness and weight loss. For me, using my Fitbit is really great because it motivates me to complete my step goal for the day and does no harm. Apps and devices like these are really useful for people and I don’t think there’s a harm in using them for your own personal gain.

 

Works Cited

“FYI, Life360 Sells Your Location Information, Driving Habits, and Registration d…: Hacker News.” FYI, Life360 Sells Your Location Information, Driving Habits, and Registration d… | Hacker News, news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20890649.

“Life360 Reviews – 2.6 Stars.” Sitejabber, www.sitejabber.com/reviews/life360.com.

Orwell, George, et al. 1984. Grasset, 2020.

Peters, Katelyn. “Quantified Self.” Investopedia, Investopedia, 26 Sept. 2020, www.investopedia.com/terms/q/quantified-self.asp.

 

Surveillance Project

Digital Diary:

  • Thursday, November 19, 2020
    • I was in bed for a total of 9 hours 8 minutes and was technically only asleep for 7 hours 31 minutes. Woke up around 8:30 which is earlier than usual but I still feel fully rested. By having the phone so close the app was able to pick up on my movement by sound and calculate exactly what I was doing. It tells me I fell asleep at 11:33 pm and that I did not snore. It even comes with a graph to show me when I was in a deep sleep, and from looking at the graph I’m able to confidently say that I slept the deepest between 5 and 7 in the morning.
  • Friday, November 20, 2020
    • I was asleep for 8 hours 51 minutes. Went to bed at 12:30 and fell asleep 30 minutes after getting into bed. I was in my deepest sleep between the hours of 3 and 4. My quality of sleep was 100%. I woke up at 10:35. I felt as though I had slept pretty heavily and I was well-rested when I awoke.
  • Saturday, November 21, 2020
    • I was asleep for 7 hours 38 minutes. Went to bed at 2:26 and fell asleep 10 minutes after getting into bed. My deepest sleep was recorded between the hours of 3 and 4, again. My quality of sleep was 98%. I woke up at 11:32. Like the previous night, I slept pretty well and I did not wake up tired.
  • Sunday, November 22, 2020
    • I was asleep for 5 hours 2 minutes. I went to bed at 3:48 and fell asleep 6 minutes after that. My sleep quality was 61%. I woke up at 9:03. Even without the tracking of the quality of my sleep, I could tell you I did not sleep so well, probably because I went to bed close to 4 in the morning.
  • Monday, November 23, 2020
    • I was asleep for 7 hours 15 minutes. I went to bed at 1:22 and fell asleep 25 minutes after that. My sleep quality was at 71%. I woke up at 9:28. I got a better night’s rest, I feel like I didn’t get into a deep sleep like the first two nights.
  • Thursday, November 26, 2020
    • I was asleep for 8 hours 30 minutes. I went to bed at 11:49 and fell asleep after 11 minutes. My sleep quality was 77%. I woke up at 9:18. Woke up around 1 in the morning but was quickly able to fall back asleep but still not the best sleep of this week.
  • Sunday, November 29, 2020
    • I was asleep for 7 hours 31 minutes. I went to bed at 11:18 and fell asleep 10 minutes after that. My sleep quality was 93%. I woke up at 8:05.

Surveillance Project

Imagining a world where your worth is based on a singular parameter whether that be by how smart or strong you are is terrifying. We preach that judging someone based on their appearance is wrong, the dystopic pieces of literature we see nowadays evolve around the mistreatment of a certain social group. We act as if we aren’t in a dystopic world ourselves but we are. What all these dystopic worlds have in common is that self-tracking is apparent and necessary. Movies from the Divergent and Hunger Games franchise depend on one’s quantified self meaning that whatever can be measured about ourselves, strength or intelligence, is taken more into account than anything else. To demonstrate this theory I will self-surveil myself by tracking my state of sleep through SleepCycle. 

You know that self-tracking is real when you have apps that can surveil you in your sleep. Unlike the fitness apps that require you to physically move your body the SleepCycle app just requires that you have your phone close by to listen to your breathing and movement. You’re not logging any information into this app, which is the main reason why I chose this app but also because when you’re asleep you’re in your most vulnerable state yet the data that’s collected ranges from whether or not you snore to what time you were in your deepest sleep. Often surveillance is easily noticeable within society either by street cameras or just recognizing that when you’re googling something there’s a chance someone is storing your search somewhere.

However, when you’re surveilling one’s sleep the parameters shift because the subject is asleep, and the only way to analyze someone in that state is by sound analysis. The data collected over the seven days go towards SleepCycles’ study on “finding your perfect wake up window, we believe you’ll be part of the change, for the benefit of better health” (SleepCycle). The benefits of this app are that you get a detailed analysis of your sleep for free. Unless you think that your sleep schedule being used for a worldwide study is bad the only limit is that to access an even more detailed version of your night you have to pay for a premium version. However, what this app does reveal is that even when you turn your phone off it doesn’t mean it stops collecting data.

Unlike Katherine Roeggla’s We Never Sleep where going days without sleep is rewarded I chose an app that revolves around one’s sleep. By monitoring my sleep I was able to better understand the parameters in which surveillance works. Eventually, by three days the app was able to calculate the quality of sleep for each night due to the information that was collected the previous days. By self-tracking myself through an app it became very clear what little I had to do to be surveilled. After waking up I would check the app and it would always feel as if it wasn’t me tracking myself because I was unconscious and unaware of what I was doing. In Roeggla’s We Never Sleep the senior associate claims “it wasn’t really him doing the job. It was more that he was playing a role” (Roeggla, 11) and to an extent, I find that very relatable when I was self-tracking. Despite being unconscious, knowing that I’m self-tracking has to factor into this “experiment”. It makes me question whether or not my sleeping pattern would be different if I had not known that an app was tracking my sleep. Being aware of this could easily not have any toll on my sleep, however, in most human experiments it’s preferred when the subject knows nothing of the actual experiment being performed. In the world of surveillance, I feel as though the information would’ve been more interesting to look at if I were unaware of the tracking. Creepy I know, to think of someone tracking you in your sleep without your knowledge but I feel like this happens more often than we realize. 

Sleep plays a huge role in one’s health. In Juli Zeh’s The Method the health of every individual is their constant priority. In this dystopian novel, the citizens are to provide their form of government with their sleep patterns along with other health records, and if an individual doesn’t submit the medical data they are held accountable for breaking a law. The protagonist, Mia, says “Since life…is meaningless and yet you have to keep going, I sometimes feel like making sculptures out of copper pipes” (Zeh, 18). I believe this is a metaphor portraying the world she lives in and how she views the system and laws by which she currently has to abide by. For example, she says she’d call these sculptures “temporary structures” maybe referring to how easily collapsible the system in place is. She even goes as far as to say that “I’d like to make something that will last” (Zeh, 18) which could easily resemble the world we live in now. We have made surveillance a permanent fixture in our lives that can easily be manipulated just like in Zeh’s novel. One’s health is considered a private matter, however, in this novel health is manipulated with the belief it could better the world they live in just as surveillance is in our world. 

The group discoveries found we’re all similar. Although no one else self-tracked their sleep, everyone was all surprised on how much data was collected from their apps. Many said they often forgot about the self-tracking until it was time to summarise the data. That point fits perfectly into my experiment because I was asleep and unaware of what was being collected almost like forgetting I was self-tracking. 

The quantified self has embedded itself within our culture forcing us to view things differently. What we prioritize, value, and become reliant on has changed drastically over the years. Through authors like Katherine Roeggla and Juli Zeh, we have come to understand the world we are becoming. By reading pieces of literature like We Never Sleep and The Method readers can easily compare the novel’s plot to today’s society, for example, surveillance. It’s all around us, intended for our own security and safety and dependent on the citizen’s little knowledge of it. Just like in the app I used for my self-tracking experiment, SleepCycle requires the bare minimum from the user. Monitoring you during the part of the day when you’re least aware, solely dependent on a device close by to listen to your movement. The bare minimum has a way of taking advantage of what little knowledge we have on the world around us.

Work Cited

Zeh, Juli, and Sally-Ann Spencer. The Method. Vintage Books, 2014. 

Röggla, Kathrin, et al. We Never Sleep. Ariadne Press, 2009. 

SleepCycle App https://www.sleepcycle.com